Carrying card or loan balances?
Will consolidating really save you money? Let's find out together.
It's easy to feel pressure to just make the payments smaller. But a consolidation loan only helps if what you pay overall goes down. Try your own numbers first, before you apply anywhere.
By Tora Mari Editorial Team · Reviewed October 13, 2026
The questions that matter
Does it lower what I pay overall, or only my monthly bill?
They're two different things. Stretching your debt over more years can shrink the payment while raising the total you pay. We show both, side by side.
Why does the fee make the loan bigger than my debts?
Lenders usually take the origination fee out before they send you the money. So to clear your debts, you have to borrow a bit more than you owe. We build that in for you.
What APR do I need to beat?
It depends on how long the loan runs. We work out your break-even APR, so you can turn down any offer above it without second-guessing yourself.
Free tool
Will my consolidation loan save me money?
Add the debts you'd like to clear and the loan you're thinking about. You'll see an honest comparison, plus the highest APR that would still leave you better off.
Runs in your browser. Nothing you type is sent to us.
Here is what we found
Good news: on these numbers the loan would save you about $3,946.34 compared with where you are now.
- You'd save
- $3,946
- All-in APR
- 17.6%
- Number to beat
- 35.6%
over the whole loan
this offer, fees included
break-even APR
Doing nothing isn't free: your debts add about $231.42 in interest every month at today's rates.
See how we worked this out
- Measure
- Today
- With loan
- Monthly payment
- $355.00
- $410.13
- Debt-free in
- 4 yr 8 mo
- 3 yr
- Interest + fees
- $7,311.08
- $3,364.74
You would borrow $12,000.00 to receive $11,400.00 after a $600.00 fee. That is what it takes to clear the debts above.
Your monthly payment would go up by $55.13, but you would be debt-free 20 months sooner.
The break-even rate, in plain words. On a 36-month term, any offer with an all-in APR below 35.6% beats your current path, and anything above it costs you more. It works however the lender splits the cost between rate and fee.
A few honest limits: we assume you keep paying today's amount on each debt until it is gone and add no new debt. Card minimums usually shrink as balances fall, so real life can differ a little. This is an illustration, not an offer or advice. Borrowing costs money, and late payments may harm your credit score.
The Break-Even Rate method
Don't chase the lowest advertised rate. Find the one you actually need to beat.
Most comparison sites rank lenders by headline rate. We start with you instead. From your own debts, we find the highest all-in APR (fees included) at which a new loan still beats doing nothing. If an offer comes in above that number, it will cost you more, however friendly the monthly payment looks.
Where our facts come from: CFPB (loan costs, adverse-action rights); FTC (lending and advertising rules); FICO (score ranges); NCUA (credit-union loan rate caps). Every tool tells you exactly what it assumed.
How consolidating works, and where the cost hides
You take out one new loan and use the money to pay off several existing debts, most often credit cards. From then on you make a single monthly payment on the new loan, at a fixed rate, over a fixed number of months. Some lenders send the money straight to your creditors; others deposit it with you and expect you to pay them off.
It's worth being honest about this: nothing here makes debt disappear. You're swapping several debts for one. Whether that's a good swap depends on the rate, the fee and the length of the new loan compared with what you have now.
To clear $11,400 of debt you borrow $12,000.
- Reaches you, pays your debts: $11,400
- Origination fee: $600
Example: three cards totalling $11,400, a 5% origination fee. The fee is taken from the loan before it reaches you, so you borrow more than you owe.
When consolidating tends to save you money
In this example that is about $3,946 less. With a higher fee or a longer term the gap can disappear, which is what the break-even tool checks.
Example: 14% rate, 36 months, 5% fee, against cards at 21.5% to 27.9% paid at today's amounts. Your numbers will differ, so test them in the tool.
- You have several balances at high rates and the new APR is clearly lower than your current average.
- You can afford the new payment comfortably, in a tight month as well as a good one.
- The new term is not much longer than the time you would otherwise take to pay off the debts.
- You have a plan so the cleared cards do not fill up again.
When consolidating tends to cost you more
- The fee and a longer term cost more than the interest you save. This is the most common trap, and the break-even tool above is designed to catch it.
- The balances are small enough to clear within a year or so on your own.
- The cards are used again after being paid off, leaving you with the loan and new card debt.
- The loan is secured by your home or car. If you fall behind, you could lose it.
- A promotional payment looks low only because the term is very long.
How to qualify, and what lenders check first
Each lender sets its own rules, so there is no single cutoff. Lenders generally look at your credit history and score, your income and its stability, and your debt-to-income ratio (your monthly debt payments divided by your income before taxes). Many lenders prefer that ratio to be well under about 40%, although this varies.
Most lenders offer prequalification, which typically uses a soft credit inquiry that does not affect your score. A formal application usually involves a hard inquiry. When you are comparing offers for the same type of loan, try to do it within a short stretch of time, since scoring models often treat several such inquiries as one.
- Check your credit reports for errors at AnnualCreditReport.com, the official free source, and dispute mistakes first.
- Pay down card balances where you can. Lower utilization often helps your score.
- Gather proof of income so you are ready if a lender asks.
- Decide in advance which debts the loan must cover and what monthly payment you can afford.
Cheaper options to rule out before you borrow
- Paying down debts yourself, either highest rate first (the avalanche method) or smallest balance first (the snowball method).
- A balance-transfer card with an introductory low rate. These commonly charge a transfer fee, and the low rate ends, so work out the cost before you rely on one.
- Nonprofit credit counseling. Agencies affiliated with the National Foundation for Credit Counseling (nfcc.org) can review your whole situation and may offer a debt management plan.
- Calling your creditors to ask about a hardship program or a lower rate.
- Be careful with debt settlement companies. The FTC advises caution, and says companies selling debt relief over the phone generally cannot charge fees before they have settled or reduced a debt.
Before you sign: the checklist that catches expensive surprises
- Get the APR, the origination fee, the term and the monthly payment in writing.
- Check the amount you would actually receive after the fee, and make sure it clears the debts you intend to pay off.
- Compare the total cost, not just the monthly payment, with what you would pay by staying on your current path.
- Look for prepayment penalties and late-payment fees.
- Decide what you will do with the cleared cards.
- Confirm the lender is licensed in your state (nmlsconsumeraccess.org and your state regulator can help).
Common questions
Will consolidating hurt my credit?
Applying usually causes a small, temporary dip because of the hard inquiry. Over time, paying cards down can lower your utilization, which may help, and on-time payments on the new loan help your history. Missing payments does the opposite. The effect depends on your own report, so there is no single answer.
Can I consolidate federal student loans with a personal loan?
You can, but think carefully. Federal student loans carry protections such as income-driven repayment plans, deferment and forgiveness programs. Paying them off with a private loan means giving those up.
Is there a minimum credit score?
It varies by lender, and some weigh income and debt-to-income ratio heavily. Prequalifying with a soft inquiry is the quickest way to find out where you stand without affecting your score.
What if I am turned down?
The lender must give you a notice explaining the main reasons and naming the credit bureau it used. You are entitled to a free copy of that report if you ask within 60 days. Fix any errors, work on what the notice identified, and reapply later or try a different type of lender.
Question not here? Ask us. The ones we hear most often get added to this list.
Borrowing costs money. Late payments may harm your credit score. Only borrow what you can afford to repay.
This content is for general education only and is not financial, legal or tax advice.
Written by the Tora Mari Editorial Team from public consumer guidance (CFPB, FTC, FICO and NCUA). Found a mistake? Tell us.